Easily Find The Best Diaper Pail: A Buying Guide

Easily Find The Best Diaper Pail: A Buying Guide

Tending to a baby and changing its diapers is already stressful enough as it is, but don’t forget that adding onto your baby-related stress can be avoided when the diaper pail you choose is a well thought out decision rather than one made on a whim.

Ultimately, going over every diaper pail design aspect will remove some of your stress rather than exacerbate it.

In fact, don’t be surprised if you develop an enhanced diaper pail shopping confidence in which you know exactly what you’re in the market for.

*Notice: On mobile devices, scroll right to see entire table.

Product Name

Our Rating

Check Price

Best Baby Diaper Pail

Winner: Ubbi Diaper Pail

Runner Up: Dekor Plus Diaper Pail

Best Odor Control Diaper Pail

Munchkin Diaper Pail

Best Simple Diaper Pail

Playtex Diaper Genie Complete Diaper Pail

Best Odorless Diaper Pail

The Diaper One N Done

On What To Pay Attention When Choosing Your Diaper Pail

Parents should strive for high buyer confidence levels since they’re less likely to make the wrong decision in regards to the best diaper pail with a mindstate that is so assertive and certain about its needs.

Size And Capacity

Diaper pails typically come in varied sizes that range from small to large, so choosing the right size entirely depends on how often you need to change your baby’s diaper.

You want to strive for a diaper pail size that promotes efficiency and cleanliness, and choosing the proper size and capacity plays a direct role.

When you see a diaper pail listed as a size small, you can easily assume that it will store up to 7 gallons worth of used diapers.

In regards to how often you'll have to take out the trash, the small-sized diaper pails typically take two days to fill up, but that only applies to newborn sized diapers.

Mom and her baby with a diaper pail in the nursery

Source: lifebylee.com

In regards to the capacity of a large-sized diaper pail, it generally holds around 14 gallons, which is ideal for those who want to minimize their weekly trips to the trash can.

A larger diaper pail will also prove to be a worthy investment since it can accommodate a higher volume of varying diaper sizes that a small-sized diaper pail simply cannot keep up with.

Which Size Best Suits Your Needs?

Since it takes about two days for a 7-gallon diaper pail to reach full capacity, you can expect that from a 14-gallon diaper pail it would take twice as long- four days!

This means you’ll have to take your diaper pail trash out a maximum of twice a week, which gives you time to focus on your baby rather than worrying about cleaning.

If you’re using a diaper pail for a newborn, a small-sized model will suffice, but don’t forget that the diaper pail’s capacity will reduce as the baby gets bigger and taller. If you want to play it safe, a large-sized diaper pail is your best option since it accommodates to your baby’s growth.

Foot Pedal

All diaper pails come with a lid that acts as a barrier between the smelly diapers and your home, but several diaper pails feature lids that come with a unique opening and closing system that is meant to make your life easier in regards to diaper changing.

Parents rave about diaper pails that include a foot pedal since it enhances the diaper pails overall user-friendliness.

The foot pedal especially comes in handy when your hands are tied up trying to change a diaper, and your foot is the only available option that can operate the lid of a diaper pail.

Odor Control

The effectiveness of a diaper pail's odor control system is what ultimately separates the best diaper pail from the average ones.

Each diaper pail is built with a unique odor control system, so it's up to you to decide as to which system best suits your needs.

Baby with a diaper pail in the nursery with dog watching

Source: mylittlekiddy.com

Some diaper pails consist of a multi-layer interior where the material composition of each layer differs so it can function as a physical barrier that locks in moisture, unwanted smells, as well as oxygen. This innovative odor control will cost you, so parents opt out to search for other options.

Fortunately, diaper pail manufacturers understand how parents don't want their house to smell of soiled diapers, so other odor control systems exist to prevent you from making a massive dent in your wallet.

A household favorite is diaper pails that come with a separate compartment meant to hold baking soda since baking soda will effectively neutralize the odors trapped inside the pail.

Other than baking soda, the liner you place inside the diaper pail also directly affects the odor control system. There are scented refill liners that help mask odors, but that's only for some particular diaper pail manufacturers.

Plastic Vs. Metal

When you take a step back, you can say that the diaper pail material can make or break its odor control system.

Parents have all come forth and agree that diaper pails with a metal build absorb odors the least while plastic models will absorb odors the most.

This makes plastic an ineffective material when it comes to odor control, but plastic continues to remain popular since it costs significantly less than metal, which is what wins some parents over.

Safety Lock

With so many new diaper pail manufacturers emerging, you’re lucky to be a consumer in a baby product market where innovation fuels growth, so you end up having more than one option when it comes to a child safety lock.

Brother reading a book to baby sister in the nursery

Source: notyourordinarymamas.com

Diaper pails without safety locks allow your baby to knock it over, crawl inside and sit in a pail liner surrounded with soiled diapers, which pose a suffocation risk.

Fortunately, child safety locks prevent your curious baby from ever making its way into the diaper pail.

When it comes to child safety lock models, you can choose a lock that opens in either a turning or a sliding motion. Most parents prefer sliding motion child safety locks since they only require one hand to successfully open and close.

Easy To Use

A diaper pail functions as your partner during a diaper change, which leads us to comprehend that a partner’s purpose is to provide a helping hand when a task is too difficult to complete.

Since your diaper pail is your partner, it should be easy for you to use and to incorporate in your diaper changing routine. You know you found a diaper pail that’s a reliable partner when you can effortlessly use it during a diaper change.

First off, disposing the dirty diapers into a diaper pail should take as much effort as breathing and little to no time. The same concept applies to the changing of the pails liner as well, so throwing out diapers should be as simple as throwing out the trash.

To see if a diaper pail can become your partner, you'll want to check out the opening and closing mechanism of its lid since some come with motion sensor activation while others require the manual use of both hands.

A word of advice from a majority of parents is that diaper pails in which a hand wave opens the lid in a matter of seconds will always be the easiest one to use.

Our Recommendations

Once you dedicate the time and effort to researching as to which design features will classify a diaper pail as the best diaper pail, you can confidently begin to search for diaper pails to add to your home.

Baby among variously colored diaper pails

Source: mums.hk

The smartest move you as a buyer can make is to write a checklist that pinpoints to each design feature you find necessary for your diaper pail to come with, so you can adhere to the checklist when you’re on the search for the final product.

Keep reading for five brief reviews of various diaper pails that may be right up your alley and end up checking off every bullet on your list.

Best Baby Diaper Pail Winner: Ubbi Diaper Pail

For those who simply want a diaper pail with a durable build, a strong odor control system, and an easy to use design have to search no further because Ubbi has met every single one of your expectations.

As a result of catering to the needs of concerns of parents and their babies, Ubbi created the Ubbi Diaper Pail, which parent's immediately accepted as their diaper change partner.

The various user-friendly design features specific to Ubbi Diaper Pail, and the ability for those features to smoothly function together creates a product that's satisfying to use rather than stressful.


  • Material: Stainless Steel (Powder-coated)
  • Accommodates any bag
  • Rubber seals
  • Covered Rim
  • Childproof safety lock
  • Sliding Hatch Door
  • Holds up to 50 newborn-sized diapers
Ubbi steel diaper pail

Source: pupsikstudio.com

Our Rating

Versatile And Cost-Effective

Parents can't get enough of Ubbi Diaper Pail because it's a product that will save them money in the long run and doesn't require the separate purchase of additional accessories to use the diaper pail properly.

When you first buy an Ubbi Diaper Pail, you receive several liner refills as well that are specially designed to hold used diapers. Once those refills run out, you’re stuck having to reorder them, which can put a massive dent in your wallet.

Fortunately, you never have to buy any liners particularly built for Ubbi Diaper Pail because any plastic bag will suffice. Parents often use Glad trash bags to save money since they're cheaper than Ubbi liners and still contain the same amount of odor.

If you alternate between using cloth diapers and disposable ones, Ubbi Diaper Pail is the only diaper pail that can properly hold both. When you take a look at this diaper pail's opening, you'll realize that it can hold more than a plastic bag since it can also hold a wet bag.

Ubbi Diaper Pail’s ability to cater to a wet bag and a regular plastic bag means that you can dispose of cloth diapers as well as disposable ones in the same place without having to buy two separate diaper pails.

Best Baby Diaper Pail Runner Up: Dekor Plus Diaper Pail

The versatile design associated with Dekor Diaper Pail solidifies its place as being the best diaper pail for cloth diapers as well as disposable diapers, so you get the best of both worlds for one single price.

For mothers using both diaper methods, Dekor Diaper Pail seems like a wish come true.

In regards to function, Dekor Plus Diaper Pail can properly store and contain odors coming from both disposable diapers and cloth diapers, but you, unfortunately, need to spend additional money acquiring the appropriate liners that can hold each particular diaper type.


  • Foot Pedal
  • Proprietary Refill Liners
  • Material: ABS Plastic
  • Limited Lifetime Warranty
  • Holds up to 60 newborn-sized diapers
  • Accommodates cloth and disposable diapers
  • Pet-friendly
Dekor Plus hands-free diaper pail

Source: 2naps.com

Our Rating

Easy To Use

Your hands are no longer needed to open and close the lid of Dekor Plus Diaper Pail, which makes this diaper pail easier to use than the one mentioned above.

You can thank the design team for Dekor for including a foot pedal located at the bottom of the diaper pail, which you can conveniently make use of one swift motion of your foot.

The simple act of pressing your foot down on the pedal will open the lid so that you can drop the used diaper in the most hygienic way possible.

Odor Control System

In regards to odor control, Dekor Plus Diaper Pail is less consistent with its results, so it’s difficult to locate a definitive answer.

Some parents will complain it doesn't contain odors well while other parents state the opposite to be true.

In fact, users claim that this diaper pail contains odors just as well as the previously mentioned best-rated diaper pail, Ubbi Diaper Pail.

Best Odor Control Diaper Pail Winner: Munchkin Diaper Pail

Out of all the diaper pail manufacturers, Munchkin is the only one that developed an advanced odor control system, which directly led to Munchkin Diaper Pail gaining a first rank title commending its superior odor control.

Other than the expert odor control abilities of Munchkin Diaper Pail, parents rave about the overall modern aesthetic that isn't common among diaper pails.

Most diaper pails are usually bulky in shape and obnoxious colors, but Munchkin Diaper Pail strays away from that design model.


  • Material: Plastic
  • Automatic Self-Sealing System
  • Lavender Scented Universal Refill System
  • Works with Arm & Hammer Refills
  • Multi-refill Compatibility: Rings & Snap, Seal & Toss bags
  • Foot Pedal
  • Dimensions: 27 inches by 12 inches
  • Childproof Safety Lock
  • Diaper Capacity: 180 newborn-sized
Munchkin Step Diaper Pail

Source: baby-find.com

Our Rating

Superior Odor Control System

Munchkin saw the potential behind the odor eliminating powers of baking soda and used it as inspiration to create an innovative odor control system that resulted in a new standard for diaper pails.

Munchkin Diaper Pail is somewhat similar to Dekor Diaper Pail since both require liners sold separately and both incorporate baking soda as a way of absorbing and neutralizing odor.

Munchkin does have a leg above Dekor since it teamed up with Arm & Hammer, which is one of the biggest baking soda providers today.

Munchkin Diaper Pail took baking soda’s usefulness to the next level when it introduced baking soda refills that specifically come lavender scented to minimize the odor damage originating from the pile of soiled diapers.

On top of the baking soda refills, Munchkin Diaper Pail included puck-shaped baking soda cartridges as well whose sole purpose is to provide additional interior odor protection with even more levels of lavender scent to mask the used diapers you’re trying to forget.

Best Simple Diaper Pail Winner: Playtex Diaper Genie Complete Diaper Pail

For the longest time parents thought Diaper Genie was synonymous for the diaper pail, so a lot of them just assumed to buy a Diaper Genie on a whim because they thought it was the only diaper pail available on the market.

At first, parents didn’t realize how Diaper Genie is a particular diaper pail whose manufacturer is Playtex. Once they started to notice other diaper pail brands, a significant amount of parents surprisingly still stuck with using Diaper Genie as their go-to diaper pail.

Playtex went above and beyond to make sure that you felt no stress assembling Diaper Genie since it comes pre-assembled and ready to use with a refill bag already installed, so all you have to do is pull it straight out of the box and start throwing away those dirty diapers.


  • Refill bags hold up to 270 newborn-sized diapers
  • No assembly necessary
  • Comes with Built in Carbon Filter
  • Included: Two Air Tight Clamps
  • Foot Pedal
  • Refill Bags: Seven Layer Build
  • Available in three colors: White, Pink, & Grey
Playtex Diaper Genie complete assembled diaper pail with odor lock technology

Source: target.com

Our Rating

Effective Odor Control

Diaper Genie consists of various odor control systems that work independently from one another but ends up providing the same fresh smelling results.

Unique to Diaper Genie are two air-tight clamps as well as a built-in odor controlling anti-microbial that play a role in effectively sealing in odors, so it never reaches the oxygen you breathe.

Another odor control system feature that you’ll only find on a Diaper Genie is a carbon filter that activates naturally to absorb and lock in used diaper odors, so your baby’s nursery immediately becomes a place of cleanliness and not days old diapers.

Diaper Genie has removed the need for you to be constantly replacing refill bags that quickly fill up with dirty diapers, which is what you’re used to doing when you use other diaper pails.

All Diaper Genie had to alter that made parent's lives so much easier is that one full-size refill now holds 270 diapers rather than a mere 30, which helps seal in odor since contact between the inside of Diaper Genie with the outside air is minimized.

Best Odorless Diaper Pail Winner: The Diaper One N Done

For those who need a cheaper diaper pail option than the ones mentioned above but still want a guarantee of consistent, high-quality diaper disposing of results, the best diaper disposal pail you'll ever find would be The Diaper One N Done.

The Diaper One N Done costs a fraction of what you would pay on average for a mid to high-grade diaper pail and doesn’t try and cheat you with cheap materials or poor overall design.

In fact, The Diaper One N Done is one of the few diaper pails to still individually seal every single one of the dirty diapers you toss in it.

The specialized bags used to complete the individually-sealed diaper disposals will cost you more money than refill bags, but you get 100 bags per unit, which will last you a long time.

In regards to the size of The Diaper One N Done, this diaper pail is extremely small and is so short and narrow that it can only hold up to three sealed diapers at a time.

This feature does make The Diaper One N Done more portable than its competition, as does this diaper pail's convenient hook design that allows you to hang it anywhere you deem suitable.


  • Individual Diaper Sealing System
  • Made in the USA
  • Comes with Optional Stand Alone Frame
  • Hook Design
  • 100 Bags per Unit
  • User Friendly
The Diaper One N Done

Source: amazon.com

Our Rating

Extensive Yet Simple Disposal System

You'll know The Diaper One N Done dual-sealing action is working when you see your soiled diaper being sealed not only once but twice after you had tossed it into this diaper pail. The double seal primarily enhances the odor control and as a result, locks the odors in.

People run into a few problems with The Diaper One N Done since it can frequently jam if you don't know how to use it and the bags will end up costing you quite a bit of money, which makes this diaper pail ideal for limited short-term use.


The five diaper pails to receive our recommendations all fit the general criteria that answer the question, what is the best diaper pail?

The best diaper pail for a mother of newborn twins would require a particular design build that would be useless for a mother with a three month-year-old baby.

Ultimately, it entirely depends on you to figure out as to which option best suits your characteristic diaper pail criteria.

Hopefully, you have a better idea as to what diaper pail you could see yourself using as part of your diaper changing station equipment.

Leave a Comment: